“High Holiday Reflections”

From the Desk of Shea Z. Lerner, New York Metro Region FJMC President


Rosh Hashanah is upon us, and there are no words, no breath left after more than eleven months of fighting, of loss, and of pain over the fighting Israel faces on all her borders and our captives held in unbearable conditions. Despite our incessant protests, vigils, demonstrations, lobbying, etc, Rosh Hashanah 5785 will arrive in all its might, even if, in our hearts, we still stand in the prayers of Simchat Torah 5784. In my many readings, I reflect upon the thoughts of Rabbi Nathalie Lastreger, Rabbi of the Minyan Mishpachati Masorti, in Kfar Vradim, Israel.

During the Musaf prayer on Rosh Hashanah, we will say more than ten times, “Today the world stands as at birth… These words—which every year inspire awe in the face of the terror of judgment that is taking place at this very moment—are said after the shofar blasts that penetrate the walls of the heart, opening a gate for supplication, compassion and hope that we may all indeed be worthy of a good life and a blessed year.

But 5784 was unlike other years; did we fail in judgment a year ago? How and why was such a terrible decree passed upon us, beginning on Shemini Atzeret and with no end yet in sight? Reflecting on the past year, despite our pleas for a good life, peace, and a sweet year – we received a bitter, terrible year, too harsh to bear.

Yet, alongside this thought, just before the door closes on 5784, we should remember every single one of the thousands and thousands of acts of kindness, bravery, dedication, and selfless love that accumulated in our nation’s account. Israel mobilized in all its glory—from near and far—to raise its banner and dignity and, most importantly, to say, like our anthem, “that our hope is not lost,” not just in words but mainly in deeds.

“Today the world stands as at birth…:” Alongside the accounting we must give of ourselves and of others regarding the past, let us remember that Rosh Hashanah, “the birth of the world,” ( Mahzor Lev Shalem)is an opportunity to be reborn as individuals and as a community, together with creation. Indeed, despite the disasters we have faced through thousands of years, we have also known how to rise, unite, and grow stronger from the fractures. And so, it will be this time as well.

This year, on the eve of Rosh Hashanah, we will shed tears with the singing of the special piyyut (liturgical poem) that opens the holiday, Achot K’tanah, which begins:The little sister prepares and arranges her prayers, O God, please heal her afflictions. End the year and its curses.” We will wholeheartedly ask that we indeed leave behind the curses and the troubles, the pains and fears of the past year, and we will conclude with words of hope for the coming year: “Be strong and rejoice, for the destruction has ended, hope in the Rock who has kept covenant with you, and ascend to Zion where we will say: Clear the paths, begin the year and its blessings.”

Let all our clubs and members unite together and work on behalf of a stronger, more united Jewish community; one that is free of antisemitism, anti-Zionism, and fear. One where we can rise up and proclaim to the heavens, Am Yisrael Chai! The People of Israel Live!

Mark your calendars for the next Biennial Convention in Chicago from July 3rd -July 6th 2025 in Chicago. Information is on the website and your club presidents have further details regarding travel info and stipends to attend.

Please visit our website, www.newyorkmetrofjmc.org for the latest happenings in your community.

To you and your families, I extend a L’shana Tova Tikatev v’ Taihatem, May you be
inscribed and sealed for a good year!


In Friendship,

Shea Z. Lerner